16th October 2015
96 views

PJ or HP?

Made by Pieguy in Debates

Hi there
Member
804 posts
726
Seen 7th November 2015
16th October 2015, 10:05 PM

Unless you are living under a rock, odds are you've heard of the book series of 'The Lightning Thief,' better known as simply 'Percy Jackson.' Same goes with Harry Potter. I mean seriously, Harry Potter is a given. So, here comes the question me and my classmates still struggle to come to a peaceful conclusion with to this day.
Although the final Harry Potter (HP) book came out in the late 90's, we still debate if it's better than Percy Jackson (PJ) or not. Personally, I fancy Harry Potter more. I find Percy Jackson to be too slow, but Harry Potter to be more suspenseful. Of course, this is just my personal opinion. What about you? If you've read at least one of either book, I'd like to know which one you prefer, so I have actual statistics to prove more people enjoy Harry Potter....muhahahahahahahahahaha!
Laterszzzzzz!
-Pie
6

+1 by Mists, trixie, Ganji, George and 2 others
Are you reading my signature?
Boring, isn't it?

cool guy
Member
1,696 posts
2,478
Seen 28th July 2022
17th October 2015, 02:02 AM

Pieguy wrote on 16th October 2015 10:05 PM:
Unless you are living under a rock, odds are you've heard of the book series of 'The Lightning Thief,' better known as simply 'Percy Jackson.' Same goes with Harry Potter. I mean seriously, Harry Potter is a given. So, here comes the question me and my classmates still struggle to come to a peaceful conclusion with to this day.
Although the final Harry Potter (HP) book came out in the late 90's, we still debate if it's better than Percy Jackson (PJ) or not. Personally, I fancy Harry Potter more. I find Percy Jackson to be too slow, but Harry Potter to be more suspenseful. Of course, this is just my personal opinion. What about you? If you've read at least one of either book, I'd like to know which one you prefer, so I have actual statistics to prove more people enjoy Harry Potter....muhahahahahahahahahaha!
Laterszzzzzz!
-Pie

A hard decision...
0



ao3 fanatic
Banned
697 posts
341
Seen 30th January 2023
17th October 2015, 02:31 AM

I <3 HARRY POTTER......... <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 <3
1

jdg
Member
1,404 posts
2,110
Seen 10th August 2023
17th October 2015, 03:23 AM

Harry potter, no sweat.
1

  • "Behind this mask there is more than just flesh. Beneath this mask there is an idea... and ideas are bulletproof." -V

Vampire Knight Is Awesome!
Member
1,334 posts
463
Seen 14th March 2016
17th October 2015, 06:37 AM

Harry Potter! :) Harry Potter is my favorite book series.
0






Vampire Knight is amazing!












Member
727 posts
245
Seen 19th November 2020
17th October 2015, 06:44 AM

Pieguy wrote on 16th October 2015 10:05 PM:
Unless you are living under a rock, odds are you've heard of the book series of 'The Lightning Thief,' better known as simply 'Percy Jackson.' Same goes with Harry Potter. I mean seriously, Harry Potter is a given. So, here comes the question me and my classmates still struggle to come to a peaceful conclusion with to this day.
Although the final Harry Potter (HP) book came out in the late 90's, we still debate if it's better than Percy Jackson (PJ) or not. Personally, I fancy Harry Potter more. I find Percy Jackson to be too slow, but Harry Potter to be more suspenseful. Of course, this is just my personal opinion. What about you? If you've read at least one of either book, I'd like to know which one you prefer, so I have actual statistics to prove more people enjoy Harry Potter....muhahahahahahahahahaha!
Laterszzzzzz!
-Pie
percy Jackson. Harry Potter only has like 7 books and 10,000 pages in all. Percy Jackson has 13 or 14 books IN ALL so that's like 30,000 pages. And I finished Harry Potter in 2nd grade
0

Member
727 posts
245
Seen 19th November 2020
17th October 2015, 06:44 AM

Tehgamer47 wrote on 17th October 2015 06:44 AM:
Pieguy said on 16th October 2015 10:05 PM:
Unless you are living under a rock, odds are you've heard of the book series of 'The Lightning Thief,' better known as simply 'Percy Jackson.' Same goes with Harry Potter. I mean seriously, Harry Potter is a given. So, here comes the question me and my classmates still struggle to come to a peaceful conclusion with to this day.
Although the final Harry Potter (HP) book came out in the late 90's, we still debate if it's better than Percy Jackson (PJ) or not. Personally, I fancy Harry Potter more. I find Percy Jackson to be too slow, but Harry Potter to be more suspenseful. Of course, this is just my personal opinion. What about you? If you've read at least one of either book, I'd like to know which one you prefer, so I have actual statistics to prove more people enjoy Harry Potter....muhahahahahahahahahaha!
Laterszzzzzz!
-Pie

percy Jackson. Harry Potter only has like 7 books and 10,000 pages in all. Percy Jackson has 13 or 14 books IN ALL so that's like 30,000 pages. And I finished Harry Potter in 2nd grade
and I chose Percy jackson
0

Member
768 posts
910
Seen 11th September 2022
17th October 2015, 07:31 AM

I never actually read these books in depth, I have not read all the books in the series. I read a few Harry Potter books, I never finished them all lawl. I have never really read Percy Jackson either, I attempted reading the Percy Jackson series and failed lol. I am guessing this is a hard decision for people who love reading and read both books. I think I would have to chose Harry Potter, I am not 100% sure.
0

The Trilogy
Member
536 posts
410
Seen 14th March 2016
17th October 2015, 07:41 AM

Percy Jackson I think is the best choice! It has great books and very interesting movies. I love the series!
1

+1 by Vivian Cruz

Member
149 posts
61
Seen 3rd November 2015
17th October 2015, 11:23 AM

Pieguy wrote on 16th October 2015 10:05 PM:
Unless you are living under a rock, odds are you've heard of the book series of 'The Lightning Thief,' better known as simply 'Percy Jackson.' Same goes with Harry Potter. I mean seriously, Harry Potter is a given. So, here comes the question me and my classmates still struggle to come to a peaceful conclusion with to this day.
Although the final Harry Potter (HP) book came out in the late 90's, we still debate if it's better than Percy Jackson (PJ) or not. Personally, I fancy Harry Potter more. I find Percy Jackson to be too slow, but Harry Potter to be more suspenseful. Of course, this is just my personal opinion. What about you? If you've read at least one of either book, I'd like to know which one you prefer, so I have actual statistics to prove more people enjoy Harry Potter....muhahahahahahahahahaha!
Laterszzzzzz!
-Pie





I read all the books of both series.



So, I do like Harry Potter, and am a Potterhead myself, but....


I prefer Percy Jackson better.


I read the Percy Jackson series first, when I was in sixth grade and continued reading them into my seventh and eighth grade years. I'm still reading them.


In my opinion, Percy Jackson is better, because once you start reading the Heroes of Olympus series, you might become obsessed like I am.


But then again, I'm watching Harry Potter and The Chamber of Secrets on TV right now irl.
1

OG ?
Master
1,498 posts
2,839
Seen 30th August 2023
17th October 2015, 01:54 PM

I used to like Harry Potter, but now I like Percy Jackson
0

it was only hypothetical
Master
6,414 posts
8,754
Seen 25th August 2023
17th October 2015, 05:26 PM

Pieguy wrote on 16th October 2015 10:05 PM:
Unless you are living under a rock, odds are you've heard of the book series of 'The Lightning Thief,' better known as simply 'Percy Jackson.' Same goes with Harry Potter. I mean seriously, Harry Potter is a given. So, here comes the question me and my classmates still struggle to come to a peaceful conclusion with to this day.
Although the final Harry Potter (HP) book came out in the late 90's, we still debate if it's better than Percy Jackson (PJ) or not. Personally, I fancy Harry Potter more. I find Percy Jackson to be too slow, but Harry Potter to be more suspenseful. Of course, this is just my personal opinion. What about you? If you've read at least one of either book, I'd like to know which one you prefer, so I have actual statistics to prove more people enjoy Harry Potter....muhahahahahahahahahaha!
Laterszzzzzz!
-Pie

Harry Potter.
1

Gone



Sweet memories







People change, memories dont
Member
887 posts
436
Seen 14th March 2016
19th October 2015, 04:58 PM

Percy Jackson/ Harry Potter, Both :3
0

I wish I was that girl

;
Member
113 posts
149
Seen 13th March 2016
21st October 2015, 12:01 PM

I don't like harry potter, so probably Percy Jackson.
0

cute
Master
719 posts
1,125
Seen 23rd February 2023
21st October 2015, 07:46 PM

I PICK PERCY JACKSON! XD
sorry for caps but Percy Jackson is so much better than Harry potter in my opinon
0

Login or join the forums to reply.