After Eiven was found dead, the staff searched the tower for any sign of the Nazgul, but no sign of their presence was seen nor felt. The only inhabitants of Baraddur were the forums staff team and maybe a lonely ghost or two.

Everyone decided to return to their rooms, except Scott who decided to admire one of the many beautiful paintings along the corridor. It was in the corridor, in front of an evil painting of Melkor and Ungoliant that Scott was found the next day. He was killed by a fountain pen. In his hand was a newspaper clipping about Player of the Month. The image was too faded and worn to make out who was in it or which platform it took place on.

Now it was certain, a murderer was indeed on the loose.

I'm guessing it's someone who is a news reporter so either 'Dice' 'Zen' or 'Sled'. Then again Damen has done FPOTM.

My bet is still on Dice for now

Its sled

Still not quite enough information but I'm going to say that the murderer is Dice since he's gone for potm a lot and he's a news reporter.

Dice

pls this is fun to read

IS DICE DICE IS VERY ACTIVE OR SLED SLED WANT HMM IDK BUT DICE IS DICE

im guessing dice bruh he movin mad

Alright, this one's a little far fetched, because the obvious pointer here is the Player of the Month hint.

But this caught my eye.

Loki wrote on 7th September 2021, 07:05 PM:

The only inhabitants of Baraddur were the forums staff team and maybe a lonely ghost or two.

TeamMaybe. An old user. Just a thought. Tensions were always high between Team and Scott anyways.

DICE ? OR SLED ?

I'm guessing Zen because she's a news reporter and she's a writer, and you write with a fountain pen.